Top 10 Hotels in New York, United States: Best Places to Stay

If you are comparing the top 10 hotels in New York, choosing the right neighborhood matters almost as much as choosing the hotel itself. Manhattan offers everything from iconic Fifth Avenue landmarks and Times Square hotels to quieter Upper East Side stays, modern West Side properties and historic hotels in Lower Manhattan.

This guide narrows the options to 10 distinctive New York hotels and explains who each one is best for, its biggest strength, and the main trade-off to consider before booking. The ranking focuses on location, character, convenience and usefulness for different types of New York trips rather than temporary room rates alone.

Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links. If you make a booking through one of these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate relationships do not determine our hotel rankings or recommendations.

New York Hotels at a Glance

Use this table for a quick comparison. Each hotel name takes you directly to its full review farther down the page.

Rank	Hotel	Best For	Area	Main Strength
#1	The Plaza	Best Overall	Fifth Avenue	Iconic New York setting
#2	The Langham	Fifth Avenue	Midtown	Central sightseeing base
#3	The St. Regis New York	Classic Luxury	Midtown	Heritage and location
#4	The Carlyle	Upper East Side	Upper East Side	Residential Manhattan atmosphere
#5	The Times Square EDITION	Times Square	Midtown	Prime Broadway-area location
#6	Pendry Manhattan West	Transport	Manhattan West	Penn Station convenience
#7	The New York EDITION	Neighborhood Style	Madison Square	Central location with character
#8	The Beekman	Historic Downtown	Lower Manhattan	Landmark atmosphere
#9	The Wall Street Hotel	Financial District	Lower Manhattan	Upscale Downtown base
#10	Hyatt Grand Central	Transportation	Midtown East	Grand Central access

#1 The Plaza, A Fairmont Hotel — Best Overall

BEST FOR: First-time luxury trips, special occasions and iconic New York atmosphere
AREA: Fifth Avenue / Central Park South
POSITIONING: Landmark luxury
BIGGEST STRENGTH: Iconic Fifth Avenue setting beside Central Park
MAIN TRADE-OFF: Travelers prioritizing Downtown or a more contemporary atmosphere may prefer another hotel

The Plaza earns our top position because few properties combine location, history and unmistakable New York identity as effectively. Its Fifth Avenue address makes it particularly compelling when the hotel itself is meant to be part of the experience.

Why We Recommend It

• One of New York’s most recognizable hotel experiences
• Excellent position for Central Park and Fifth Avenue
• Especially strong for milestone trips and special occasions

WHO SHOULD SKIP IT? Travelers who expect to spend most of their trip in Lower Manhattan may find a Downtown property more convenient.

---

#2 The Langham, New York, Fifth Avenue — Best for Fifth Avenue

BEST FOR: Sightseeing-focused luxury trips
AREA: Midtown / Fifth Avenue
POSITIONING: Luxury
BIGGEST STRENGTH: Exceptionally central Fifth Avenue base
MAIN TRADE-OFF: Midtown is busy and may not suit travelers seeking a quieter neighborhood stay

The Langham is an excellent fit for visitors who want Manhattan’s major sights within easy reach. Its Fifth Avenue location puts Grand Central, Times Square and major shopping and cultural destinations within a practical central radius.

---

#3 The St. Regis New York — Best Classic Manhattan Luxury

BEST FOR: Classic luxury and special occasions
AREA: Midtown / Fifth Avenue
POSITIONING: Historic luxury
BIGGEST STRENGTH: Heritage combined with a prime Midtown address
MAIN TRADE-OFF: Less suited to travelers looking for modern boutique minimalism

The St. Regis is a strong choice for travelers who want traditional Manhattan luxury. Its Fifth Avenue and 55th Street location places Central Park, Rockefeller Center, Fifth Avenue shopping and MoMA close at hand.

---

#4 The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel — Best Upper East Side Stay

BEST FOR: Museums, Central Park and a quieter Manhattan experience
AREA: Upper East Side
POSITIONING: Classic luxury
BIGGEST STRENGTH: Residential-feeling Upper East Side setting
MAIN TRADE-OFF: Less convenient for visitors focused on Times Square and Downtown

The Carlyle is the standout choice here for travelers who prefer the Upper East Side to Midtown’s intensity. Its Madison Avenue location is one block from Central Park and well positioned for the neighborhood’s museums, galleries and boutiques.

---

#5 The Times Square EDITION — Best for Times Square

BEST FOR: Broadway, first visits and travelers who want to be in the center of the action
AREA: Times Square
POSITIONING: Contemporary luxury
BIGGEST STRENGTH: Times Square location
MAIN TRADE-OFF: The surrounding area is extremely busy

The Times Square EDITION makes sense for visitors who actively want the Times Square experience rather than merely convenient access to it. Broadway theaters and Midtown attractions are the primary reason to choose this location.

---

#6 Pendry Manhattan West — Best for Penn Station & Manhattan West

BEST FOR: Rail travelers, Hudson Yards and contemporary design
AREA: Manhattan West
POSITIONING: Contemporary luxury
BIGGEST STRENGTH: Convenient access to Penn Station and the West Side
MAIN TRADE-OFF: Less traditional New York atmosphere than the landmark hotels farther east

Pendry Manhattan West is particularly useful for travelers arriving by rail or planning to spend time around Hudson Yards and the High Line. Its West Side position makes it one of the most practical contemporary luxury choices in this ranking.

---

#7 The New York EDITION — Best for Madison Square

BEST FOR: Design-conscious travelers who prefer a neighborhood-oriented Manhattan base
AREA: Madison Square / Flatiron
POSITIONING: Contemporary luxury
BIGGEST STRENGTH: Central location outside the Times Square tourist core
MAIN TRADE-OFF: Not as convenient for Central Park as the Fifth Avenue hotels

The New York EDITION offers a useful middle ground between Midtown sightseeing and a more neighborhood-focused stay. Its Madison Square location works particularly well for exploring Flatiron, NoMad and surrounding parts of Manhattan.

---

#8 The Beekman, A Thompson Hotel, by Hyatt — Best Historic Lower Manhattan Stay

BEST FOR: Historic character and Lower Manhattan sightseeing
AREA: Lower Manhattan
POSITIONING: Historic upscale
BIGGEST STRENGTH: Distinctive landmark atmosphere in Downtown Manhattan
MAIN TRADE-OFF: Farther from Central Park and Midtown’s major attractions

The Beekman is our preferred historic Downtown choice. Its Lower Manhattan position offers a more characterful alternative to a conventional Financial District business hotel while remaining useful for Downtown sightseeing.

---

#9 The Wall Street Hotel — Best for the Financial District

BEST FOR: Financial District trips and upscale Downtown stays
AREA: Financial District
POSITIONING: Upscale boutique
BIGGEST STRENGTH: Strong location for Lower Manhattan
MAIN TRADE-OFF: Less convenient for travelers whose itinerary revolves around Midtown

The Wall Street Hotel is the most targeted choice on this list for travelers who specifically want the Financial District. It provides an upscale base for Lower Manhattan and the nearby Seaport area without requiring daily travel from Midtown.

---

#10 Hyatt Grand Central New York — Best for Transportation

BEST FOR: Transportation convenience, first visits and sightseeing-heavy trips
AREA: Midtown East
POSITIONING: Large full-service hotel
BIGGEST STRENGTH: Grand Central convenience
MAIN TRADE-OFF: Less distinctive than the luxury and boutique hotels higher in the ranking

Hyatt Grand Central is the practical choice in this ranking. Its Midtown East position makes it particularly useful for travelers who expect to rely heavily on public transportation or want a straightforward base for exploring Manhattan.

Where to Stay in New York

MIDTOWN: The most straightforward choice for many first-time visitors because major sights, Broadway, Fifth Avenue and extensive transportation options are concentrated nearby. The Langham, St. Regis, Times Square EDITION and Hyatt Grand Central each serve different Midtown travelers.

UPPER EAST SIDE: Better for travelers who prioritize Central Park, museums and a more residential Manhattan atmosphere. The Carlyle is the clear match in this ranking.

MANHATTAN WEST: Particularly convenient for Penn Station, Hudson Yards and the High Line. Pendry Manhattan West is the strongest fit.

MADISON SQUARE / FLATIRON: A useful compromise for travelers who want central Manhattan without staying directly in the Times Square tourist core. The New York EDITION is our choice here.

LOWER MANHATTAN: Best for travelers focused on the Financial District, World Trade Center area, Downtown history and the Seaport. The Beekman and The Wall Street Hotel provide two different upscale options.

Which New York Hotel Should You Choose?

For an iconic first New York luxury stay, start with The Plaza. Choose The Langham when central Fifth Avenue convenience is the priority, The St. Regis New York for classic Manhattan luxury, or The Carlyle for a quieter Upper East Side experience.

If Broadway and Times Square dominate your plans, The Times Square EDITION makes more sense. Rail travelers should look closely at Pendry Manhattan West, while The Beekman and The Wall Street Hotel are better suited to Downtown-focused itineraries. For transportation convenience, Hyatt Grand Central New York is a particularly practical choice.

How We Chose the Top 10 Hotels in New York

Our ranking considers location, traveler type, transportation convenience, atmosphere, distinctiveness and how well each hotel serves a particular type of New York trip. We deliberately included hotels across several Manhattan neighborhoods rather than treating temporary nightly price or a single review score as the deciding factor.

The purpose of these top 10 hotels in New York is to provide a useful shortlist rather than suggest that one property is universally right for everyone. A first-time sightseeing trip, romantic weekend, business visit and Downtown-focused vacation can require very different hotel locations.

Affiliate relationships do not determine the ranking. Rates, availability, amenities, cancellation policies and other booking details can change, so verify current information with the booking provider before making a reservation.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best area to stay in New York for a first visit?

Midtown is usually the easiest starting point for a first visit because many major attractions and transportation connections are nearby. Travelers who prefer a quieter atmosphere may instead favor the Upper East Side.

Which New York hotel is best near Central Park?

The Plaza is our strongest overall recommendation for an iconic stay near Central Park. The Carlyle is an excellent alternative for travelers who prefer the Upper East Side.

Which hotel is best for Times Square and Broadway?

The Times Square EDITION is the clearest choice on this list for travelers who specifically want to stay in the Times Square and Broadway area.

Which New York hotel is best for train connections?

Pendry Manhattan West is particularly convenient for Penn Station, while Hyatt Grand Central New York is the practical choice for Grand Central access.

Should I stay in Midtown or Lower Manhattan?

Midtown generally works better for first-time sightseeing, Broadway and Central Park access. Lower Manhattan can be a better choice if your plans center on Downtown attractions, the Financial District or the World Trade Center area.